Simon Róbert

The Social Anatomy of Islam


Part 1: The birth and shaping of a society

This book sets out to provide further materials on the anatomy of Islamic society, a social structure sui generis. In so doing, it will be able to derive important apposite support from the work of such as Alfred von Kremer (1828–89), J. Wellhausen (1844–1914), I. Goldziher (1850–1921) or Claude Cahen (1909–91). Fact is seldom self-evident by nature, as Plato's Socrates teased out of his interlocutors by the method of maieutikē, or midwifery. In social studies, we can rely on the necessarily abbreviated, one-sided, and most often misleading written sources and monuments of the material culture that serves daily life, and these generally seldom point beyond themselves. In the study of history, we know that it is possible to build the stage of history right up to the nineteenth century "on the storms in the cloud region of politics", as Marx put it. That provided material for political history even to such as Ranke, as well. The twentieth-century historical approach broke radically with that view, and economic history, the Braudelian longue durée observation, mindset history and the discovery of the micro-world of everyday things have created the possibility of examining the "metabolism" of society in greater depth. Despite the significant efforts of great scholars in the past, it seems that much remains to be done in research into Islamic society. The present attempt too rather formulates problems and questions, and attempts to touch on a number of topics that previous studies have neglected. A fundamental question is whether the various elements of society (economy, institutional system, culture, Islam that determines processes as a "preponderant factor", the corresponding societal forms, the individual's room to move, the social role of variously rooted intelligentsia) are capable of forming an organic whole. The persistent and morbid lack of the latter plays a basic part in ever worse responses to historical challenges and in incapacity for development.

The Social Anatomy of Islam

Tartalomjegyzék


Kiadó: Akadémiai Kiadó – Felsőbbfokú Tanulmányok Intézete

Online megjelenés éve: 2024

ISBN: 978 615 574 253 8

This work analyses some essential features of the classical as well modern Islamic society. Islam cannot be regarded as a religion in the strict sense of the word, because civil change marginalized it and made it into societally insignificant movement in the private sphere. Some consider it a kind of a politically organized formation, but politically unified Islamic society disintegrated from the second half of the ninth century, independent units came into being reproducing the original model. Others are of the opinion that Islam is an ideology. This, however, would mean that during one and a half millennium the Muslims gave wrong answers to the different challenges. Some consider Islam as a culture, but this concept is a category of civil society subjected to permanent change. Therefore, we shall interpret Islam as society-integrating network which organized its own society, the umma on the principle of repristination or retraditionalisation.The main topics treated in the first part of our work are: the problem of genesis; the hermeneutics of the main concepts of Political Islam counterpointed by the categories of Ibn Khaldún’s power-state; integration and stratification of society; forms of changes (reform, revolt, revolution). The second part is dealing with the problems of modern Islam, taking into account revivalist movements from the Khárijites to the Islamic State.

Hivatkozás: https://mersz.hu/simon-the-social-anatomy-of-islam//

BibTeXEndNoteMendeleyZotero

Kivonat
fullscreenclose
printsave