8.3.1. Domestic scholars of Polizeiwissenschaft

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

Polizeiwissenschaft/scientia politico-cameralis meant the cultivation of political science with a predominance of public administration, often, but by no means exclusively, a police-oriented cultivation in German-dominated scholarship, although its origins go back to 1705, to the concept of science de police1 by the Frenchman Nicolas Delamare (1639-1723), who is considered the founder of public administration science with his four-volume work published over 29 years (and who, incidentally, had already dealt with the issue of poverty in this main work).

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

The role and importance of the cultivation of cameralism/cameralistics and Polizeiwissenschaft in Hungary becomes obvious if we make it clear that by the 18th century, Hungary suffered a slight disadvantage in terms of university education compared to other countries, but the institution of peregrinatio academica was able to partially make up for this deficiency from the early Middle Ages onwards. The first major permanent Hungarian university, the Universitas Tyrnaviensis/University of Trnava (Hun. Nagyszombat), was founded in 1635, and the institution began offering legal education in 1667. In 1769, Maria Theresa/Maria II (1717-1780, reign: 1740-1780) ordered the establishment of the Department of Politico-cameralis (i.e. Polizeiwissenschaft), which in Hungary was still the university’s Trnava (Nagyszombat) period. Initially (between 1769 and 1777), the subject was taught at the Faculty of Humanities in Trnava (Nagyszombat), and the subject, which was otherwise reserved for lawyers, was taught by theologians.

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

Its first (appointed) professor was the Buda-born Antal (Károly) Weissengruber (17262 -1792; taught: 1769-1770), a student of the famous late Austrian Polizeiwissenschaft theorist, Joseph von Sonnenfels (1732/1733-1817; taught: 1763-c. 1802), perhaps the most significant practitioner of the discipline. The unfortunate Weissengruber suffered such a permanent physical disability due to a riding accident that he could never teach; he was only a formally appointed professor. Earlier, a Hungarian Sonnenfels student of Croatian origin, Béla Albert Barics (1742-1813; taught: 1769-1813), or, according to other sources, Adalbert Barits, was appointed to the Varaždin Law Academy, and later to the Zagreb Law Academy. (Incidentally, he was the rector of the Royal University of Pest between 1785 and 1786). Thus, the choice for the Hungarian professorship fell on Gáspár Ehrenfels (c. 1740-1792; taught: 1770-1772) (according to other sources, he used his name as Gáspár Paál Ehrenfels or Gáspár Pál Ehrenfels), who had studied science privately and was examined and selected by Joseph von Sonnenfels. He spoke six languages (Hungarian was probably his native language) and, as a canon of Bratislava (Pozsony), headed the Doctrinal Committee of the Council of Governors from 1777. We assume Ehrenfels has left behind a printed book on the subject,3 however, this is only a standard examination thesis form (Lat. thesis; Ger. Sätze)4 for doctoral dissertations,5 where the praeses Straller and the professor Ehrenfels are listed (these forms are listed under the professor’s name by bibliographers, but sometimes only the candidate’s name is listed in the form). As an interesting addition to our research on Polizeiwissenschaft, which began in 2010, we found the form of the examination thesis of Ferenc Gyurkovics (c. 1740-1794; taught: 1772-1794), the later professorial successor, also from 1771, under the presidency of Ehrenfels, where the author is also the contemporary professor, Ehrenfels,6 since the professor is considered the intellectual formulator of the thesis, as the examination theses were personalised. Gyurkovics taught the subject at the Faculty of Humanities until 1777, and then at the Faculty of Law. In addition, he was also the rector of the Royal Hungarian University of Sciences in 1782-1783. Also worth mentioning is the legal scholar Pál Rosos de Szentkirályszabadja (1751-1809), bishop of Veszprém, who wrote a work in Latin on internal security in 1777, but did not hold a professorship. Incidentally, he crowned Queen Maria Ludovika [Maria Luisa of Spain] (1745-1792), Holy Roman Empress, Queen of Hungary in Bratislava (Hun. Pozsony). Maria Ludovika donated 100,000 gold forints to the Ludoviceum/Ludovika Military Academy (now: Ludovika University of Public Service), which was later named after her.7

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

The most outstanding representative of the Hungarian Polizeiwissenschaft was József Reviczky de Revisnye (1750-1815; taught: 1794-1805), who was the most significant Hungarian lecturer and researcher in the field and subject of scientia politico-cameralis. (As an aside, his family was one of the oldest noble families of Árva County, located on the northern Hungarian linguistic border). In 1790, he was appointed to the department as a reward for writing his main work, Introductio ad politica Regni Hungariae, which was published without indicating the author.8 The volume mainly contains an examination of internal security issues.

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

In the second chapter of the work, we encounter the social question: the topic of poverty. Reviczky speaks to an even lesser extent about the issue of poorhouses, beggars, orphans, and usury (and perhaps pubs, as one of the results of usury).9

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

Reviczky makes a special mention of the miserable condition (Lat. spuriorum status miserabilis) of illegitimate children (in his wording: bastards),10 saying that they are excluded from later (family-law-inheritance) advancement. Those who were ‘conceived in an illegitimate bed’ (Lat. ex illegitimo thoro nati) are not only excluded from inheriting anything, but they cannot hold any civil office (Lat. Civilibus Officiis).11

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

Thus, avenues for the advancement of the poor were largely blocked in the era. This way of thinking partly anticipates the dilemma of protecting the property of the rich versus protecting the poor (Fr. protéger la propriété du riche, protéger la pauvre) posed by Louis Blanc (1811-1882), which led to the triple motto of the French public administration of the era: ‘order, justice and charity’ (Fr. ordre, justice et charité).12

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

It must be said that Reviczky’s volume provides an interesting cross-section of the meeting of the old and the new approach to Polizeiwissenschaft, which is enriched by examples of Hungarian laws by the author, whose willingness to analyse laws is a novelty compared to the works of German-speaking authors.

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

A later work is Politia civitatis by Ferenc Huber (1786-1844; taught: 1817-1844), who taught scientia politico-cameralis, i.e. political science/public administration-based Staatswissenschaften, at the Reformed Law Academy in Cluj-Napoca (Hun. Kolozsvár).13

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

The work only lists legal and not literary sources. Among its topics, the early germs of public administration policy, population census, and administrative organisational law may be of interest to us. Within internal security, he examines specific issues (especially issues related to livelihoods): grain shortages and pofiteering (Lat. annona caritas), wood (lat. ligna), salt (Lat. sal), poor-quality food (Lat. noxia alimentorum qualitas), water (lat. aqua), bad air (lat. aëris insalubritas) and also deals with what the public administration should do in individual cases. (This in itself carries a kind of demand for the environment, and for sustainability, which was not yet known by name at the time). This case is a preliminary example of modern usage of the concept before the term ‘sustainability’ existed.14

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

That is, the lack of grain, wood, salt, the unfitness of (fresh) water for human consumption, and action against bad air are partly social, poverty issues, but the proposal is partly a kind of anticipation - through the involvement of everyone - of the actions to be taken against later environmental problems. The mention of food donations is explicitly part of the fight against poverty, while the ban on poor-quality food is also given in this context, and is also one of the first seeds of today’s food safety public administration action. It should be noted that Delamare’s French-language work dealt in quite some detail with the fight against poor-quality food.15 Moving along these questions, Huber mainly elaborated on the issues of health administration (Lat. sanitatis administri).16

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

The examination of the above fundamental questions indicates the author’s social sensitivity, which was as much a characteristic of the scholars of the era as his deeply experienced and sincere religiously based morality.

Jegyzet elhelyezéséhez, kérjük, lépj be.!

Other Hungarian teachers of Polizeiwissenschaft were, in the order of the beginning of their teaching time: the Ruthenian (and perhaps partly Slovak) Mihály Balugyánszky (Mihajlo Baludjanszky) (1769-1847, in Hungary/country of origin taught: 1789-1803; abroad [Russian Empire] taught: 1803-1813); Mihály (János Nepomuk) Sax (1750-1824; taught: 1806-1819); The names of István Gyurián (1761-c. 1840, taught: 1821-1830), Péter Tipula (1794-c. 1870, taught: 1832-1849), and László Bercsényi (c .1810s-c. 1850s, taught: 1848-1849) should be mentioned among the scholars of the department.17
 
1The manuscript of this sub-chapter was closed at 01.03.2025. Delamare, N. (1705-1734). : Traité de la police, où l’on trouvera l’histoire de son établissement, les fonctions et les prerogatives de ses magistrats, toutes les loix et tous les réglements qui la concernent: on y a joint une description historique et topographique de Paris & huit plans gravez qui representent son ancient état & ses diverses accroissements avec un recueuil de tous les statuts et réglements des six corps marchands & de toutes les communautés des arts et métiers I-IV. (Paris:Michel Brunet - Jean Cot et Pierre Cot – Jean-François Hérissant). 1496. . ISBN no.
2 Our most reliable lexicographic sources (the 14-volume basic source work entitled The Lives and Works of Hungarian Writers by József Szinnyei, and the continuation of his work by Pál Gulyás and János Viczián) do not deal with his life either. The only source for his birth time and status: Csekey I. (1957). Balugyánszky Mihály élete és munkássága. [The life and work of Mihály Balugyánszky/Mihajlo Baludjansky]. Századok [Centuries], 91(1-4) 327-328. Csekey records him as Károly Weissengruber. Research has not yet clarified, due to the lack of sufficient sources, whether biographies are mixed, as Károly Weissengruber is recorded as a grammar teacher at the Pécs gymnasium until 1814. On this topic, see: Kiss A. F. (1914). A pécsi gimnázium története. [History of the Pécs high school]. (Pécs:Taizs Nyomda) 172.
3 Ehrenfels, C. (1771a). Sätze aus der allgemeinen Einleitung in die Staatswissenschaft, aus der Polizey (!), und Handlungswissenschaft welche nach den Vorlesungen…Josephus Straller vertheidigen wird... (Nagyszombat: [s. n.]). .30. ISBN no.
4 List of examination thesis/Sätze in this case list of theses/possible questions for the doctoral oral examination/thesis defending, which was customary to publish in print. Together with the doctoral dissertation, or separately from it. In the case of separate printing, it was put on sale independently, or sometimes tied to another work. It was customary to distribute it at the doctoral defense as well.
5 Koi G. (2005). Egyetemi jogirodalmi könyvkiadás 1775-1800. 66 könyvészetileg ismeretlen nyomtatvány az Eötvös Loránd Tudományegyetem Állam- és Jogtudományi Kar Kari Könyvtárában. [University legal literature publication 1775-1800. 66 bibliographically unknown prints in the Faculty Library of the Faculty of Law and Political Sciences of Eötvös Loránd University]. Jogtörténeti Szemle [Legal History Review], 7(2) 81-93. Koi G. (2005). Adatok 1800 utáni egyetemi jogirodalmi könyvkiadásunkhoz. Könyvészetileg ismeretlen nyomtatványok az Eötvös Loránd Tudományegyetem Állam- és Jogtudományi Kar Kari Könyvtárában, valamint az ELTE Egyetemi Levéltárban. [Data for our university legal literature book publication after 1800. Bibliographically unknown prints in the Faculty Library of the Faculty of Law and Political Sciences of Eötvös Loránd University and in the ELTE University Archives]. Acta Facultatis Politico-Iuridicae Universitatis de Rolando Eötvös Nominatae, 2006. 43 (1) 241-280.
6 Ehrenfels, C. (1771b). Sätze aus der allgemeinen Einleitung in die Staatswissenschaft, aus der Policey (!), welche nach den Vorlesungen…Caspars Ehrenfels…Franciscus Xaverius de Gyurkovics den Monat Julii 1771. von 4. bis 6 Uhr Nachmittag vertheidigen wird auf den hohen Schule Tyrnau. (Nagyszombat: [s.n.]) unknown length of the text. ISBN no. The copy is currently kept by the Esztergom Cathedral Library [Hun. Főszékesegyházi Könyvtár (Esztergom)].
7 Rosos P. (1777). Dissertatio juris publici universalis de interna rerum publicarum securitate. (Pest: Royer). ii, 232, (1). ISBN no.
8 [Reviczky J.] (1790). Introductio ad politica Regni Hungariae. (Buda:Egyetemi Nyomda). 172, (12). ISBN no.
9 Reviczky (1790) op. cit. 34-90.
10 According to today's Hungarian family law terminology, the correct term is children born out of wedlock, but the term was not known at the time.
11 Reviczky (1790) op. cit. 82.
12 Reviczky (1790) op. cit. 82-83
13 Huber F. (1829). Politia civitatis, cum applicatione ad Transsilvaniam. Kolozsvár, 1829, (Kolozsvár:Református Kollégium Nyomdája). iv, 224, (1). ISBN no.
14 Huber (1829) op. cit. 49-68.
15 Delmare (1705-1734) op. cit. II. 1096-1105.; II. 1396-1399.
16 Huber (1829) op. cit. 74-100.
17 Koi G. (2025). A közigazgatás tudományos vizsgálatának egyes elméleti kérdései. (Tankönyv a Közigazgatás MA képzés számára Közigazgatás-elmélet tantárgyból). [Some theoretical issues of the scientific study of public administration. (Textbook for the MA program in Public Administration, Public Administration Theory subject)]. (Budapest:Ludovika Egyetemi Kiadó). 33-34. (Under publication).
Tartalomjegyzék navigate_next
Keresés a kiadványban navigate_next

A kereséshez, kérjük, lépj be!
Könyvjelzőim navigate_next
A könyvjelzők használatához
be kell jelentkezned.
Jegyzeteim navigate_next
Jegyzetek létrehozásához
be kell jelentkezned.
    Kiemeléseim navigate_next
    Mutasd a szövegben:
    Szűrés:

    Kiemelések létrehozásához
    MeRSZ+ előfizetés szükséges.
      Útmutató elindítása
      delete
      Kivonat
      fullscreenclose
      printsave