Sohár Anikó (szerk.)

Tripliciter dicere

Szokott és szokatlan fordítási jelenségek


2 A few translation trajectories

The first Japanese translation was done in 1952 and has become widely read despite of omissions from the original text. To date more than 30 new translations have been published (Akamatsu 2019: 216). The popularity of the book is also due to the presence of a Japanese animation series adaptation of Anne of Green Gables done in 1979, but also to several other factors, such as a museum exhibition at the Fukuyama Literary Museum titled Anne of Green Gables: Journey to Prince Edward Island in 2004. Based on the research by Rubio, Akamatsu points out that Montgomery highlights the natural wonders of Prince Edward Island and joins in “the province’s desire to develop tourism in the 1903–1907 period” (Rubio 2008: 257 quoted in Akamatsu 2019). Akamatsu sees Montgomery’s intentions being realised by the fact that the Japanese readers not only ‘consume’ the translated fiction and the cultural products such as anime films, but often also engage in tourism.
Anne of Green Gables was first translated into Sweden in 1909, only one year after the publication of the source text, and it has been in print since then. Regarding Swedish translations, Warnqvist points out legal rights issues, and the marketing practices of the publisher targeting a younger age group compared to adult readers in Canada, making changes to adjust the text for that purpose (2013: 228–242). Norwegian scholarship includes the study of Montgomery’s text from the point of view of omissions and textual manipulations (Erdmann and Pettersson 2019). Studies on Polish versions highlight issues of retranslation done in 2022 by Bańkowska, after the first translation of Bernsteinowa in 1911 (Wieczorkiewicz and Dukátová 2024).
According to an academic initiative done in eight countries of the Central European Association for Canadian Studies (Sparling and Kürtösi 2019), Montgomery is not only popular, but is the most translated Canadian author in Central Europe, that is the highest number of titles have been translated from her oeuvre. While nearing Hungary geographically, let us look at the translation trajectories of the neighbouring countries that have a similar geo-political context.
Anne of Green Gables was translated into Slovak during the Communist era, in 1959 under the title Anna zo Zeleného domu by the publishing house Mladé letá located in Bratislava which was part of Czechoslovakia at the time. Otrísalková and Gazdík (2012) have traced the translation of English Canadian Literature into Slovak language from the beginnings up to 2012. Regarding the entrance of the Montgomery translations into the literary field, they link the books with a larger political move. “Towards the end of the 1950s, when political pressure lessened as a result of a socio-political ‘thaw’ that set in after Krushchev’s denunciation of Stalin’s personality cult, publishers sought to re-establish continuity with the years immediately following the Second World War” (Otrísalková and Gazdík 2012: 120). Before 1990, three titles were translated into Slovak: Anne of Green Gables in 1959, Anne of Avonlea in 1969, Anne of the Island in 1969. The authors make note of the fact that although the books went through 11 reprints and were immensely popular, Montgomery’s critical assessment is still missing probably due to the fact that the series were labelled as children’s literature which at the time was not considered “serious literature.”
In the same volume of publications, Otrísalková examines the translation of Anne of Green Gables into Slovak. She emphasises that the heroine, Anne Shirley, was compatible with the Socialist ideals. As a teacher, Anne took up responsibility in society and in the local community, she was active outside the home, and also fulfilled a care-giving role as a mother. Otrísalková points out regarding the textual completeness that the text was heavily censored. All references to religion, the words such as ‘God’ or ‘Christianity’ as well as complete sentences were omitted from the Slovak version hindering understanding at certain places. Interestingly, the Slovak publisher has been using this text which was censored in 1959 and has not initiated retranslation despite Montgomery’s popularity (Otrísalková and Gazdík 2012: 174). The film series appeared in 1993 on Slovak Television (Otrísalková and Gazdík 2012: 170). The bibliographic catalogue thus shows that in the former Czechoslovakia, young adults grew up in the Communist era with the stories of three Montgomery books from the 1950s, while this was not the case in Hungary. Let us turn to Montgomery’s reception in Hungary which varies significantly from cases of Western Europe but even that of Czechoslovakia. The date of the Hungarian publication is comparable to the timing of the Bulgarian translation, which appeared in 1993, or the Croatian translation in 1997.
 

Tripliciter dicere

Tartalomjegyzék


Kiadó: Akadémiai Kiadó

Online megjelenés éve: 2026

ISBN: 978 963 664 228 0

A kötet tizennégy fordítástudományi tanulmányt vonultat föl, négy részben. Az első rész a fordítás és egyetem alcímet viseli, három tanulmánya a fordítás és oktatás témakörét járja körbe két kísérlet és egy utánkövetés formájában. A második rész három fordítástudományi elemzést tartalmaz, melyek közül kettő a műfordítók helyzetét vizsgálja, a harmadik pedig magát a fordítástudomány tárgyát osztályozza. A harmadik rész konkrét műfordításokra összpontosít és három esettanulmányt sorakoztat föl: a példák egy olasz történelmi regény angol, német és magyar fordításai, illetve a kanadai-magyar műfordítási áramlatból, valamint egy hazai irodalmi együttműködésből származnak. A negyedik rész öt, kiemelkedő jelentőségű, eredetileg angolul írt fordítástudományi munka magyar fordítását tartalmazza, amelyeket a Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem fordító és tolmács mesterszakos hallgatói, illetve fordítástudományi kutatásokat végző doktoranduszai készítettek.

Hivatkozás: https://mersz.hu/sohar-tripliciter-dicere//

BibTeXEndNoteMendeleyZotero

Kivonat
fullscreenclose
printsave