Sohár Anikó (szerk.)

Tripliciter dicere

Szokott és szokatlan fordítási jelenségek


4 L. M. Montgomery books in Hungary

The political change of 1989 affected the publishing scene in a subversive way and brought about structural change in the field (see e. g. Garton Ash 1995, Laki 2008, Lux & Horváth 2018). New authors and genres were introduced from the West, including authors from Canada. The first translation of the Anne series with the translation of Anne of Green Gables entered the Hungarian market through Európa Publishing House, the largest publishing house transferring world literature in 1992. Interestingly, the publishing process was preceded by thorough reviewing, a practice that was lingering in the post-1989 era before selection became based on scout recommendations, pitches and best seller lists. Five in-house reviewing reports have been found in the publisher’s archives, in which one report may contain an opinion on several books (Anne of Green Gables, Anne of Avonlea, Anne of the Island, Anne of Windy Poplars, Anne’s House of Dreams, Rainbow Valley, Rilla of Ingleside, Anne of Ingleside in 1991, Anne of the Island and Tales of Avonley in 1996, Days of Dreams and Laughter in 1996, Rilla of Ingleside in 1996, and one on Anne of Avonlea and Anne of the Island is without a date). Four out of five reviews highlight the success of the four-part film adaptation of the Anne books made in Canada in 1985 and 1987, as well as its 1992 launch on the Austrian and the Hungarian Television. There is no trace of Montgomery being reviewed in Európa earlier than 1991.
The 1991 report highlights the immense success of Anne of Green Gables even after 80 years of the original publishing. The reviewer compares the popularity of the Anne books with the American children’s book series Little House in the Prairie, as well as with the Hungarian “Cilike” stories which date back to the beginning of the 1900s. The reviewer states that the success of the Anne books can be attributed to the character portrayal of the protagonist, the precise description of both society and nature, and a noticeable religious morality. The report highlights that two popular film adaptations as well as a theatre play were based on the book. In the following year, the Anne of Green Gables were published in Hungarian translation (translated by Katalin Szűr-Szabó, see Table 7.1.).
The 1996 reviewing document explains that the four volume book series titled Váratlan utazás [Unexpected Journey] (published in 1993, 1994, 1995, translated by Zsuzsa Rakovszky) is falsely accredited to Montgomery as they are only inspired by her books, she is not the author per se. The movie tie-in books follow the storyline of the CBC and Disney Chanel TV series titled Road to Avonley which were directed by Kevin Sullivan and screened in Canada between 1990 and 1996. In Hungary, the TV series were dubbed and screened on the Hungarian National Television between 1993 and 1997. The episodes were merely inspired by Montgomery’s The Story Girl and The Golden Road which novels were translated in 1999 at Európa Publishing House with the title Mesélő lány (translated by Katalin Gádoros and Győző Ferencz), and Az arany út in 2000 (translated by Katalin Gádoros). The mentions of the film adaptations – both Anne of Green Gables and the Montgomery inspired Road to Avonley – in the publisher’s in-house documents as well as in the readers’ online forums are important to note as they have always been part of the cultural assemblage that Montgomery’s books travelled with.
Table 7.1. shows the titles that have been translated into Hungarian (listed according to the date of publication).
 
Table 7.1. Translated L. M. Montgomery books in Hungarian
Title of original
EN published
Title of translation
HU first published (time between original– translation)
Translator
Hungarian
Publisher, date of first publishing and reprints
Anne of Green Gables
1908
Anne otthonra talál
1992 (84)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Európa (1992, 1993, 1994, 1997), Könyvmolyképző (2004, 2011, 2018), Lazi (2021, 2022)
Anne of Green Gables
1908
Anne a Zöld Oromból
New translation (115)
Júlia Morcsányi
Manó Kv. (2023)
Anne of Avonlea
1909
Anne az élet iskolájában
1993 (84)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Európa (1993, 1994, 1995), Könyvmolyképző (2005, 2008, 2013, 2017), Lazi (2021)
Anne of the Island
1915
Anne válaszúton
1994 (79)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Európa (1994, 1999), Könyvmolyképző (2006, 2011), Lazi (2022)
Anne of Windy Poplars
1936
Anne új vizekre evez
1995 (59)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Európa (1995), Könyvmolyképző (2007, 2011), Lazi (2022)
Anne’s House of Dreams
1917
Anne férjhez megy
1996 (79)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Európa (1996, 2007), Könyvmolyképző (2007) Lazi (2023)
Anne of Ingleside
1939
Anne családja körében
1997 (58)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Európa (1997), Könyvmolyképző (2008, 2012),
Lazi (2023)
Rainbow Valley
1919
Anne és a Szivárvány-völgy
1997 (78)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Európa (1997), Könyvmolyképző (2008)
Rilla of Ingleside
1921
Anne gyermekei a háborúban
1998 (77)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Európa (1998), Könyvmolyképző (2009)
The Story Girl
1911
A mesélő lány
1999 (88)
Katalin Gádoros, Győző Ferencz
Európa (1999)
Emily
1923
Emily
1999 (76)
Vera Loósz
Esély Mozaik (1999), Könyvmolyképző (2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010)
The Golden Road
1913
Az arany út
2000 (87)
Katalin Gádoros
Európa (2000)
Christmas with Anne: and Other Holiday Stories
1995
Anne karácsonya
2005
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Könyvmolyképző (2005, 2008, 2020)
The Blue Castle
1926
A kék kastély
2008 (82)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Könyvmolyképző (2008)
Chronicles of Avonlea
1912
Avonlea-i krónikák
2008 (96)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Könyvmolyképző (2008)
Further Chronicles of Avonlea
1920
Avonlea-i krónikák 2.
2010 (90)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Könyvmolyképző (2010)
Pat of Silver Bush
1933
Ezüst Erdő úrnője
2012 (79)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Könyvmolyképző (2012)
Mistress Pat
1935
Pat úrnő
2016 (81)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Könyvmolyképző (2016)
A Tangled Web
1931
Gubanc
2017 (86)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Könyvmolyképző (2017)
Kilmeny of the Orchard
1910
Kilmeny a gyümölcsöskertben
2023 (113)
Gerda Barcza
Lazi (2023)
The Blythes are Quoted
2009
Gleni ​krónikák 1: Anne és a „Hajdanvolt” mesék
2024 (15)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Lazi (2024)
The Blythes are Quoted
2009
Gleni ​krónikák 2
2025 (16)
Katalin Szűr-Szabó
Lazi (2025)
 
It is worth noting that while the most recent translation came out only 15 years after the English language publishing, the largest time span between original and translation is 115 years. In most cases, the time lap falls between 70–80 years, as a result of which, the socio-historical contexts of the original and translation considerably vary. One of the most striking examples is Rilla of Ingleside that depicts the involvement of Canada in World War I through the story of Anne’s children. The book was originally published only a few years after the war, in 1921, and contains the personal memories of the author trying to come to terms with the horrors of the war. The entrance of the Hungarian translation on the other hand into the Hungarian literary field is quite different. Sohár (2022: 246) points out regarding translated popular genres during the Kádár era that a Communist mass culture was created which involved novel series named ‘Pöttyös könyvek’ and ‘Csíkos könyvek’ [Dotted Books, Striped Books] produced for teenage girls. These series had an educational motive behind the simple storyline. After the political transformation, a new cultural need was filled by the Anne series which arrived in the place of this programmatic literature in 1992, and Rilla of Ingleside in 1998. Montgomery’s books thus filled a vacuum and a very different socio-economic need in the target culture in the post-Communist era compared to the source culture.
Although Montgomery initially wrote her novels and short stories for adults and wished to share her personal experience with women on the topics of raising children, being a pastor’s wife, living in Canada during a world war, etc., the books became popular with adolescent and teenage girls as well. In the target culture, the translations were positioned for the younger generation from the start and were presented as such by the publisher which can be traced especially in the illustrations. Most of the illustrations in Európa’s published titles were done by Krisztina Rényi, a renowned Hungarian graphic artist who recreated the characters according to her own visual interpretation which clearly differs from the image presented in the film series. Most of the drawings depict only the contour lines of the characters, thus, those pages can be used as a colouring activity for children. Additionally, in the catalogue of the Szabó Ervin Metropolitan Library in Budapest, Montgomery’s books appear under the category of ‘children’s literature’ and can be located in the children’s library section.
The Hungarian translations of Montgomery’s books were produced by six publishers: Európa, Könyvmolyképző, Lazi, Manó Kv., Esély Mozaik, and Fabula. Európa’s portfolio became very diverse in the 1990s, as it had to publish a variety of genres including fast sellers and YA novels to cover raising publishing costs. In 1992, Európa acquired the translation rights for Anne of Green Gables. Miklós M. Nagy, former director of Európa, shared1 that in the publication of the consecutive translations, he also had a personal motivation: his daughters were avid readers of the Montgomery series. Európa published 10 titles, then released the rights. Next, Könyvmolyképző located in the city of Szeged (South Hungary), focusing on young adult readers, picked up the rights. Later, when Európa wanted to publish Montgomery again, the rights were still contracted by Könyvmolyképző. Currently, the rights are with Lazi, also located in the city of Szeged. This small publisher releases Hungarian and world literature, various genres from young adult literature to science fiction, fantasy, academic books, history, philosophy, psychology and often reprints earlier translations of literary pieces that are free of royalties (e.g. Jane Austen). The Montgomery books at Lazi are positioned slightly differently compared to the earlier publisher as the books are listed under the tab “International Literature” rather than “Children’s and YA Fiction”.
1 Personal interview with Miklós M. Nagy on 28 February 2019 at the headquarters of Libri in Budapest.

Tripliciter dicere

Tartalomjegyzék


Kiadó: Akadémiai Kiadó

Online megjelenés éve: 2026

ISBN: 978 963 664 228 0

A kötet tizennégy fordítástudományi tanulmányt vonultat föl, négy részben. Az első rész a fordítás és egyetem alcímet viseli, három tanulmánya a fordítás és oktatás témakörét járja körbe két kísérlet és egy utánkövetés formájában. A második rész három fordítástudományi elemzést tartalmaz, melyek közül kettő a műfordítók helyzetét vizsgálja, a harmadik pedig magát a fordítástudomány tárgyát osztályozza. A harmadik rész konkrét műfordításokra összpontosít és három esettanulmányt sorakoztat föl: a példák egy olasz történelmi regény angol, német és magyar fordításai, illetve a kanadai-magyar műfordítási áramlatból, valamint egy hazai irodalmi együttműködésből származnak. A negyedik rész öt, kiemelkedő jelentőségű, eredetileg angolul írt fordítástudományi munka magyar fordítását tartalmazza, amelyeket a Pázmány Péter Katolikus Egyetem fordító és tolmács mesterszakos hallgatói, illetve fordítástudományi kutatásokat végző doktoranduszai készítettek.

Hivatkozás: https://mersz.hu/sohar-tripliciter-dicere//

BibTeXEndNoteMendeleyZotero

Kivonat
fullscreenclose
printsave